Top Toilet Paper
Based on community reviews & Amazon ratings
Members Mark TP
Good quality for the price; much better than Kirkland; occasional lint/dust issues
Charmin Ultra Strong
A strong, high-quality, non-linty paper; preferable to Scott and Costco; known to be harsh by some
Charmin Ultra Soft
The gold standard for softness; better than Ultra Strong/Essentials; a quality upgrade from Kirkland
Scott 1000
Septic-safe and plumber-recommended; reliable with 25 years of use; prevents clogs better than thick brands
Cottonelle Ultra Clean
A strong alternative to Charmin; does not cause fingers to rip through; better than the linty Kirkland brand
Target Up & Up Ultra Soft TP
A perfect, affordable dupe for Charmin Ultra Soft; soft, thick, and not dusty; a better value than Costco/Charmin
Amazon Presto! Ultra Strong
Affordable, strong, and lint-free; a good value option; preferable to its Ultra Soft variant
Quilted Northern
Softer than Scott 1000; good for sustainable practices; dissolves better than Charmin
Cottonelle
A long-term preference for its quality; better than sandpaper-y store brands; not prone to crumbling/shedding
Angel Soft
Dissolves quickest for plumbing; a happy switch from other brands; a good functional option